Search engines and other websites collect user data to provide a better user experience. Sometimes, that data gets abused too. Whether you respect your privacy or it is the nature of your work, more people are turning to privacy-focused browsers of late to protect their identity and what they do online.
Tor has made a name for itself when it comes to anonymous browsing, and Brave is looking to grab a piece of that market.
Tor (The Onion Router), also popularly called the Onion browser, was initially developed by the US Navy but is now a non-profit organization that works towards to goal of providing private access to the uncensored web through the concept of onion routing. That means it moves your Internet data (encrypted) across many servers run by volunteers across the world.
Brave browser is a free and open source browser which blocks ads and trackers. Brave also proposes a future browser with a ‘pay to surf’ business model with roots in blockchain and cryptocurrency. You have an option to enable ads allowing trackers, and if you do share your data and view ads, you get paid in BAT, Brave’s native cryptocurrency. Recently, they released a new feature called New private window with TOR leaving users perplexed as to which browser is more secure and how they differ.
So which one should you use to ensure a more private browser experience? Let’s find out.
1. Open Source Base
The Tor browser consists of technologies that include a modified Mozilla’s Firefox browser, specific Tor proxy, script blocking extension, and HTTPS Everywhere Firefox extension. In short, it is built using several open source technologies.
On the other hand, Brave browser is based on the Chromium web browser which is an open source project by search engine giant Google. Chrome and Microsoft’s new Edge browser are built on the Chromium web browser.
While users continue to debate over which one is better when it comes to blocking ads, scripts, and devtools, the consensus is that Firefox is more private of the two and gives you more control over which scripts are allowed.
2. Security & Privacy
The crux of the debate is how secure and private the Brave browser is compared to Tor, especially after the Tor integration into the former. Tor uses onion routing, its proprietary technology, where your Internet data is first encrypted and then bounced around a network of relays that are run by volunteers. Tor implements multi-layer encryption which means data is encrypted before relayed to the next server in the network. See how onions have multiple layers too? Hence the name.
Tor also blocks all ads, scripts, and recommends users not to install any browser plugins. It also deploys NoScript and HTTPS Everywhere by default.
Brave browser blocks all ads, requests, and third-party cookies by default too and uses both NoScript (not on by default upon installation) and HTTPS Everywhere. For a browser that sells privacy and security, Brave dev team caused quite a controversy when they decided to whitelist certain domains including Facebook ad tracking URLs.
Following a Twitter uproar, they were forced to release a statement yet the update was not reversed. In fact, they went on to add a Twitter URL to the whitelist. The whitelist is hard coded and users cannot edit it.
Firefox does a better job and offers more privacy and security options to users, and hence more control. For one, Firefox uses its certificate trust chain instead of the OS you are using and two, you can configure the proxy settings. Brave Browser could have done something similar. On the plus side, Brave disables Google account and sync services disallowing them to track you.
3. New Private Window with Tor
To win the trust back, Brave Browser introduced ‘New private window with Tor’ feature with Tor integration as an option for privacy and security savvy users. The Tor integration is available for desktop browsers only for now so mobile users are left out.
When a user asked what the fundamental difference between Tor browser and Brave Browser’s Tor integration is on Reddit, the company admitted that Tor is more secure while Brave is suitable for hiding from ‘ISP, work or school.’ On the plus side, the default search engine is set to DuckDuckGo in the Tor mode.
Brave with Tor does not provide the same level of privacy as the Tor browser
To me, that sounds like a proxy or a VPN, but Tor is much more than that. Where Tor hides your fingerprint more effectively, Brave Browser has a ‘slightly more unique fingerprint.’
Finally, any new security vulnerability and a subsequent patch will be available to Tor users first and then browsers that are using Tor’s services.
4. Revenue Model and Platforms
The company behind Tor browser is a non-profit organization, and they depend on donations for research and development. Tor is available on Windows, macOS, Android, and iOS platforms.
Brave browser has a system called Brave Rewards that will show targeted ads to users selected by the team. In return, users will receive BAT token that they can then distribute to their favorite YouTuber, Twitch channels and other content creators. Or, users may decide to keep the tokens to cash out at a cryptocurrency exchange like Binance.
The idea is to create a win-win situation where the browser rewards the users for allowing ads and sharing data willingly for a piece of the pie. While it is voluntary and users will have to opt-in, that does raise questions about data. Brave is available on all popular desktop and mobile OS, but Tor integration was released for Windows and macOS only with a promise to bring it to Android and iOS soon.
Onion Has More Layers
Here is the summary. Brave browser is safe and secure, and rewarding for viewing ads voluntarily. A nice concept. Brave is trying to do the right thing by bringing Tor in to the fold which makes it more private than say, Chrome’s Incognito Mode.
However, Tor is still the go-to browser when it comes to staying anonymous on the web, protecting your identity and data from prying eyes. It’s like Brave Browser team says, if your life depends on it, use Tor.